Apple Pay rewards and loyalty capabilities could help address one of the key disadvantages open-loop mobile wallets have traditionally faced compared with merchant-specific payment apps. Closed-loop wallets such as those offered by Starbucks and other major merchants have been able to encourage repeat usage by combining payments with gift cards, loyalty programs, and meaningful customer rewards.
Apple’s partnership with Blackhawk Network sought to narrow that gap by integrating prepaid and gift cards, e-gifts, and merchant loyalty programs into Apple Pay. Bringing payments and rewards together could give consumers more reasons to use Apple Pay regularly rather than simply replacing the physical card they would otherwise use at checkout.
Open-loop mobile wallets have struggled to reach the levels of use that closed-loop wallets have because the typically do not offer the same kinds of rewards. Starbucks Coffee Co. remains the leader in mobile payments, but Apple Pay is trying to catch up with the help of Blackhawk Network.
Apple addressed a glaring hole in Apple Pay on Monday, when Blackhawk Network announced that it will integrate gift cards, e-gifts, loyalty and rewards programs into the mobile payment system.
The partnership between the two companies will enable Apple Pay users to make payments using prepaid and gift cards, and will also allow users to earn rewards and loyalty points from participating merchants, according to a press release from Pleasanton, California-based Blackhawk.
Despite this addition, Apple Pay will still face stiff competition from closed-loop apps. For companies like Dunkin’ Donuts, Starbucks, and Cumberland Farms, a closed-loop mobile app lowers payments costs and allows the ability to offer richer rewards to consumers.
Apple Pay rewards and loyalty integration represented an important step toward making the wallet more competitive with successful closed-loop payment apps. Payments alone may offer consumers convenience, but loyalty points, gift cards, and other incentives can create stronger reasons for repeated mobile wallet usage.
Closed-loop apps still retain important advantages, including lower payment costs and greater control over customer relationships and rewards. Apple Pay’s challenge is to combine the broad acceptance of an open-loop wallet with the engagement that has made merchant-specific mobile payment programs successful.
Overview by Ben Jackson, Director. Prepaid Advisory Service at Mercator Advisory Group
Read the full story here
