Bank branch closures are becoming an increasingly important issue as financial institutions look for opportunities to reduce operating costs. FDIC data showing a decline in the number of U.S. bank branches raises questions not only about changes in banking strategy, but also about how branch reductions could affect communities that rely heavily on physical banking services.
Concerns are particularly significant when closures occur in low- and moderate-income communities, where consumers may have fewer alternatives for accessing traditional financial services. However, determining whether banks are disproportionately withdrawing from these neighborhoods requires a more detailed examination of individual branch closures and the circumstances surrounding each institution’s decisions.
Recently released FDIC data shows that in 2010, for the first time in 15 years, the number of bank branch offices declined in the US. The decrease was relatively small, from 99,550 to 98,517 (or barely 1% change) representing the net of branch closures and branch openings. Given the continuing consolidation throughout the banking industry, not to mention the stresses of the past several years and the continuing lackluster economy, banks can hardly be blamed for seeking out opportunities to reduce their respective cost structures.
The author of this New York Times article posits that the closings have been concentrated in low to middle income areas, and expresses concern over the lack of CRA enforcement with respect to the role of banks in serving under-banked neighborhoods. He quotes a former regulator:
“In a competitive environment, banks are cutting costs and closing branches, but there are social costs to that decision,” said Mark T. Williams, a banking expert at Boston University and a former bank examiner for the Federal Reserve. “When a branch gets pulled out of a low- or moderate-income neighborhood, it’s not as if those needs go away.”
Assessing the Impact of Bank Branch Closures
Although all communities do need banking services, one cannot accurately assess the banks’ motivations without examining the data at the individual branch level and on an individual bank basis. It would make an interesting project to really prove a point one way or the other, but this article doesn’t delve that deep. Instead it makes generalized allegations about what might be true. The policy issues behind the subject are legitimate, and deserved more serious assessment than this story gave them.
The decline in the number of U.S. bank branches reflects broader changes taking place across the banking industry, including consolidation, economic pressures, and efforts by financial institutions to control costs. At the same time, reducing physical locations can have consequences for communities where consumers depend on branches for access to banking services.
Understanding the true impact of bank branch closures requires more than looking at national totals or drawing conclusions from individual examples. Examining where branches are opening and closing, the characteristics of the communities involved, and the strategies of individual financial institutions would provide a stronger foundation for evaluating whether certain neighborhoods are disproportionately affected and what role banking policy should play in maintaining access to financial services.








