Big (Alternative) Data in Credit Decisioning

The growing use of alternative data in consumer lending is challenging traditional approaches to evaluating creditworthiness. Online lenders and peer-to-peer (P2P) lending platforms are exploring information beyond conventional credit reports, including social media activity, online shopping habits, geographic location, and digital behavior. These emerging credit scoring techniques offer the possibility of extending financing to borrowers who have limited credit histories or difficulty qualifying through established lending channels.

Companies such as Lenddo, LendUp, and Wonga are among those experimenting with alternative credit assessment methods, while technology providers such as Kreditech are developing tools to analyze unconventional borrower information. Although these approaches could improve access to credit, they also introduce significant questions about consumer privacy, data transparency, and the extent to which lenders should be permitted to examine an applicant’s digital life.

How Alternative Data Is Changing Credit Scoring

Slate Wednesday published a blog post profiling a number of companies involved in P2P lending and online short-term and payday lending which rely on social networking data from borrowers to help gauge credit risk. The post also examined the technologies available to the companies via vendors such as Kreditech.

Social Media and Behavioral Data in Lending Decisions

Lenddo, LendUp, and Wonga all use such alternative data and scoring technologies to help screen applicants. Some of the elements involved in these types of alternative screening processes can include location data (GPS, micro-geographical), social graph (likes, friends, locations, posts), behavioral analytics (movement and duration on the webpage), people’s e-commerce shopping behavior and device dats (apps installed, operating systems). The core thesis of the piece:

All these efforts are premised on the sensible idea that current models of assessing creditworthiness focus on too few indicators, shutting off many potential borrowers who pay their bills on time but don’t have good (or any) credit histories. “Big data” can separate the lazy slackers from those who truly deserve better loan terms. The goal, then, is to get as many data as possible, perhaps even nudging potential applicants to pre-emptively disclose as much information about themselves as possible.

Balancing Financial Inclusion With Consumer Privacy

The focus of the blogger’s argument is privacy. Even though new technologies may facilitate greater access to credit, what is the price in terms of personal privacy for those needing expanded access?

The use of alternative data in credit scoring presents an opportunity to expand financial access for consumers who may be underserved by traditional lending models. Borrowers with limited credit histories, including younger adults and individuals who have primarily relied on cash transactions, may benefit from assessment methods that consider a broader range of financial and behavioral information.

However, collecting additional information does not automatically produce fairer or more accurate lending decisions. Social media connections, geographic location, browsing behavior, and device characteristics may reflect circumstances unrelated to a borrower’s willingness or ability to repay a loan. If lenders rely too heavily on these indicators, alternative scoring systems could introduce new forms of bias while attempting to overcome the limitations of conventional credit assessments.

Transparency is another important consideration. Consumers may not fully understand which personal details lenders collect, how that information influences their credit eligibility, or whether they can challenge decisions based on inaccurate or misleading data. These concerns become particularly significant when borrowers feel compelled to disclose extensive personal information in exchange for access to financing.

Ultimately, the future of alternative credit scoring depends on finding an appropriate balance between innovation, financial inclusion, and consumer protection. Lenders seeking to use social networking and behavioral data must consider whether the information meaningfully improves risk assessment and whether its collection is justified. Expanding access to credit is a worthwhile objective, but it should not require consumers to surrender unnecessary amounts of personal privacy.

Click here to read more from Slate.

Exit mobile version