Black Friday is undergoing a significant transformation as ecommerce reshapes how consumers approach holiday shopping. What was once a single day of crowded stores and limited-time discounts is becoming an extended promotional season, with retailers launching deals weeks before Thanksgiving. The changing Black Friday shopping trends are creating new opportunities for merchants with strong digital capabilities while placing additional pressure on traditional department stores.
Retailers such as Amazon, Target, and Walmart are positioned to benefit from their established online platforms and omnichannel strategies. Meanwhile, mall-based chains face growing challenges as shoppers increasingly compare prices and make purchases from their computers and mobile devices. With a shorter holiday shopping calendar this year, the competition for consumer spending is intensifying.
Ecommerce Transforms Black Friday Shopping Trends
Black Friday ain’t what it used to be. Winners will be big merchants with finely tuned e-commerce channels and mega-marketing budgets. Think Amazon, Target, and Walmart. Losers will likely be mall-centric stores such as JCPenney, Kohl’s and Macy’s. Black Friday was formerly the key day when shoppers would flock to stores and buy up a storm. Retailers would offer their best deals as key incentives to visit stores. E-commerce has changed all of this. Merchants now offer online deals starting in early November through Christmas, turning the day of Black Friday into Black Friday season.
Omnichannel Retailers Gain an Advantage During the Holidays
Even Cyber Monday deals that Amazon made big have spilled over across days and weeks through November and December. Merchants that have perfected a true omni-channel strategy will reach the hybrid shopper no matter where there are: mobile device, computer, or in-store. The calendar also shows that there are six less shopping days this year between Thanksgiving and Christmas—another reason why merchants start their marketing blitz well ahead of Turkey Day. Our outlook is for robust consumer holiday spending with year-over-year increases in the 4-5% range, but the retail landscape will continue to change going into 2020 and the New Year will bring more store closings. Holiday shopping sales results will determine who those will be. Stay tuned.
Department Stores Face Declining Black Friday Traffic
According to CNBC, department stores such as Macy’s, Kohl’s, and JCPenney face mounting challenges as Black Friday loses its traditional importance. With retailers offering promotions weeks in advance and consumers increasingly comparing prices online, the appeal of limited-time doorbuster deals is diminishing.
Traditional Doorbuster Deals Lose Their Appeal
It’s true, there are still the traditionalists, who feel the holidays aren’t complete without a post-turkey trip to the mall. These are the shoppers who thrive by lining up in the cold, waiting for a retailer’s doors to open in the wee hours of the morning, hoping to score a deeply discounted kitchen appliance or office gadget. Department stores in particular are known for handing out those kinds of doorbuster deals, which are only available in limited quantities for a short period of time. But today, with the internet at consumers’ fingertips, the appetite to jockey through crowds for coupons or “buy one, get one” offers has waned.
The evolution of Black Friday reflects a broader shift in retail, where convenience, competitive pricing, and digital accessibility increasingly influence purchasing decisions. Merchants that successfully integrate online and physical shopping experiences are better positioned to capture holiday spending, while department stores must find new ways to attract customers.
Although overall holiday sales are expected to remain strong, the benefits may not be distributed evenly. Retailers with established ecommerce operations and substantial marketing resources have significant advantages in reaching consumers throughout the extended shopping season.
As Black Friday shopping trends continue to evolve, the holiday season could prove decisive for struggling retailers. Sales performance will help determine which merchants can adapt to changing consumer expectations and which may face additional store closures as the industry enters 2020.
Overview provided by Raymond Pucci, Director, Merchant Services, Mercator Advisory Group.








