PaymentsJournal
SUBSCRIBE
  • Analysts Coverage
  • Truth In Data
  • Podcasts
  • Videos
  • Industry Opinions
  • News
  • Resources
No Result
View All Result
PaymentsJournal
  • Analysts Coverage
  • Truth In Data
  • Podcasts
  • Videos
  • Industry Opinions
  • News
  • Resources
No Result
View All Result
PaymentsJournal
No Result
View All Result

SEC Official Says Ether Isn’t a Security, but that’s Not Necessarily Good News

Aaron McPherson by Aaron McPherson
June 15, 2018
in Analysts Coverage
0
Using a Card To Buy Things Connected to Crypto? Fear the Tax Man!?

Using a Card To Buy Things Connected to Crypto? Fear the Tax Man!?

2
SHARES
0
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on LinkedIn

At the Yahoo Finance All Markets Summit: Crypto conference on June 15, William Hinman, the director of the division of corporation finance at the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, surprised many people by declaring that the cryptocurrency Ether was not a security, because “In cases where there is no… central enterprise being invested in or where the digital asset is sold only to be used to purchase a good or service available through the network on which it was created,” that digital asset is “out of the purview of U.S. securities laws.” This might appear to be good news, because it seems to indicate less regulation for Ether, which has been at the heart of many cryptocurrency innovations, including the booming Initial Coin Offering (ICO) market.  However, the picture is more nuanced, as this article from TechCrunch suggests:

For the SEC, while cryptocurrencies like bitcoin and ether are not securities, token offerings for stakes in companies that are built off of those blockchains can be, depending on the extent to which third parties are involved in the creation or exchange of value around the assets.

The key for the SEC is whether the token in question is being used simply for the exchange of a good or service through a distributed ledger platform, or whether the value of the cryptocurrency is dependent on the actions of a third party for it to rise in value.

“Promoters, in order to raise money to develop networks on which digital assets will operate, often sell the tokens or coins rather than sell shares, issue notes or obtain bank financing. But, in many cases, the economic substance is the same as a conventional securities offering. Funds are raised with the expectation that the promoters will build their system and investors can earn a return on the instrument — usually by selling their tokens in the secondary market once the promoters create something of value with the proceeds and the value of the digital enterprise increases,” Hinman said.

This gets at the heart of an old problem in cryptocurrency and blockchain, the issue of governance.  Effectively, in order to avoid being a security, a cryptocurrency cannot have an owner or other body that regulates and governs its use.  Yet many cryptocurrencies of particular interest to payments providers, such as RXP (Ripple), do have such a body; in fact, the existence of a governance body is what gives financial institutions confidence in investing in the platform.  Ether itself was originally a security by this definition, since the Ethereum Foundation presold it in order to raise money to fund development of its scripting language.  What does it mean to be using a security as a substitute currency?  In other words, this is an answer that raises a whole host of questions, as can be seen in a follow-up article in CoinDesk on June 15 called “Rejoice or Bemoan? SEC’s Ether Comments Divide Crypto”.

In short, the regulatory landscape is still very unsettled, with different agencies and different courts in different countries giving widely divergent opinions about what is going on in the cryptocurrency market.  This is likely to have a chilling effect on blockchain initiatives, as financial institutions become nervous about getting too far out ahead of the regulators.  For those who fantasized about a stateless financial infrastructure, this is a vivid reminder that states and regulators retain immense power to punish people retroactively for conduct that was not obviously illegal at the time they did it.  For all that cryptocurrencies may exist independently of states, the people who use them do not, and they move forward at their own risk.

Overview by Aaron McPherson, Vp Research Operations at Mercator Advisory Group

Tags: CryptocurrenciesEthereumSEC
2
SHARES
0
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on LinkedIn

    Analyst Coverage, Payments Data, and News Delivered Daily

    Sign up for the PaymentsJournal Newsletter to get exclusive insight and data from Javelin Strategy & Research analysts and industry professionals.

    Must Reads

    digital value

    How Embracing Digital Value Can Help Solve the B2C Payments Conundrum

    June 1, 2023
    instant payments, real-time payments, RTP

    Banks Developing Instant Payments Products in the U.S. Should Focus on Billers to Generate New Revenue Streams  

    May 31, 2023
    Digital Wallet Use Delivers on Convenience and Security

    Digital Wallet Use Delivers on Convenience and Security

    May 30, 2023
    5 Ways to Protect Your Financial Institution from a Cyberattack

    5 Ways to Protect Your Financial Institution from a Cyberattack

    May 26, 2023
    traditional banks

    How Traditional Banks Can Modernize Without Risk

    May 25, 2023
    identity fraud

    Javelin’s Identity Fraud Study Highlights the Changing Nature of Fraud

    May 24, 2023
    SASE, security-as-a-service

    Security-as-a-Service Secures
    Distributed IT Models

    May 23, 2023
    mule. real-time

    Early Detection of Mule Activity Requires Real-Time Solutions

    May 22, 2023

    Linkedin-in Twitter

    Advertise With Us | About Us | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Subscribe
    ©2023 PaymentsJournal.com

    • Analysts Coverage
    • Truth In Data
    • Podcasts
    • Videos
    Menu
    • Analysts Coverage
    • Truth In Data
    • Podcasts
    • Videos
    • Industry Opinions
    • Recent News
    • Resources
    Menu
    • Industry Opinions
    • Recent News
    • Resources
    • Analysts Coverage
    • Truth In Data
    • Podcasts
    • Industry Opinions
    • Faster Payments
    • News
    • Jobs
    • Events
    No Result
    View All Result

      Register to download this complimentary report from Brightwell: