The Biggest Risk for Private Label Card Programs Isn’t Competition—It’s Stagnation

The Target Circle Card is one of the leading examples of the private label card model, demonstrating how payments can be integrated with loyalty and rewards to drive customer engagement.

But the appeal of the Circle Card extends beyond cashback rewards and delivery perks. Like other leading private label programs, it offers convenience and security, enabling customers to pay in stores and across apps, websites, and digital wallets.

Many private label programs have yet to embrace these capabilities, with some continuing to rely primarily on physical cards— some still using basic magnetic-stripe cards without chips — and more traditional security measures. As consumer expectations shift toward seamless digital experiences, these limitations are becoming increasingly difficult to ignore.

“When private label issuers fail to keep up, their payment cards risk becoming invisible in customers’ everyday payment journeys—moving from out of the wallet to out of mind, and ultimately out of use,” said Alex Weaving, Chief Commercial Officer for Digital Payment Solutions at IDEMIA.

“Modernization is not just a card upgrade,” he said. “With the right strategy, private label issuers can transform their payment cards—whatever their form factor—from a payment instrument into a strategic platform to ensure brand engagement, loyalty, and long-term growth.”

A Critical Tension

One of the defining characteristics of a private label card is its closed-loop structure. This gives issuers considerable flexibility to tailor programs to a wide range of brands and use cases, from retail and employee benefits to fleet networks.

For brands, private label cards can provide valuable customer data, greater control over the payment experience, and opportunities to integrate payments more closely with rewards and loyalty.

However, the limited acceptance of closed-loop systems is increasingly at odds with consumer behavior. Customers now expect seamless digital experiences, including instant access to newly approved cards and easy integration with mobile wallets.

When customers must wait for a physical card to arrive, manually enter card details at checkout, or navigate separate processes for payments and rewards, the resulting friction can undermine engagement.

Security presents another challenge. Closed-loop products are not inherently more secure, especially when programs rely on magnetic-stripe cards or SMS-based authentication, which can leave them vulnerable to skimming, phishing, and credential compromise.

By and large, these challenges are pushing issuers to rethink the traditional private label model.

“Many issuers are now facing a critical tension—the strengths of the closed-loop model are no longer sufficient in a world where consumers expect instant, seamless, and secure experiences across every channel,” Weaving said. “In today’s digital payment environment, a closed-loop model that has not evolved alongside changing consumer expectations can limit acceptance, slow modernization efforts, expose security vulnerabilities, and create friction in the customer experience.”

Security Is the Foundation

For issuers still relying on outdated payment technologies, migrating to EMV chip cards and contactless payments is an important first step. These upgrades can improve in-store security and convenience, but they do not, on their own, address the risks associated with digital payments.

“Some mid-tier retailers, benefits, or fleet card issuers built their infrastructure 10 to 15 years ago and still run non-tokenized primary account number (PAN)-based systems—especially in e-commerce—exposing sensitive credentials and slowing the transition to digital payment experiences,” Weaving said.

“True card security demands end-to-end tokenization that covers every transaction channel: mobile, in-store, and online,” he said. “A fragmented tokenization landscape means a single weakness can expose the entire ecosystem.”

Tokenization offers another layer of protection by replacing a card’s PAN with a unique digital credential for payment and storage. When implemented consistently across channels, tokenization reduces exposure of the underlying card number during digital transactions.

Achieving that consistency, however, can be a hurdle. A program might support tokenization in mobile wallets while continuing to store actual card numbers in its app or e-commerce systems, leaving gaps in its security strategy.

Issuers therefore need to consider the entire credential lifecycle through an omnichannel lens, from issuance and storage to transmission and use. A comprehensive approach can strengthen security across the payment journey without introducing unnecessary friction for customers.

“Security is no longer just about stopping fraud,” Weaving said. “It is about enabling better experiences and protecting customer trust. Tokenization has become the foundation of private label cards in the digital world, enabling wallets, one-click checkout, card-on-file, and future commerce models.”

Playing to Strengths

The mobile app is one of the most important channels in a modern private label program. It brings payments, card management, and rewards together in a single interface, giving customers a central place to interact with the brand.

A well-designed app can let users tap to pay with an emulated digital card, add a newly approved card to a digital wallet immediately, receive real-time transaction alerts, and manage card settings. Just as importantly, it can make rewards easier to track and redeem while surfacing offers that encourage repeat engagement.

Monizze Pay, by Belgian employee benefits provider Monizze, provides a concrete example of how this can work in practice. Integrated directly into the Monizze app, it enables users to make contactless payments with their meal, eco and gift vouchers on iOS and Android, while allowing Monizze to retain control of the customer journey, brand experience and payment environment.

E-commerce is another priority. Embedded payment options, such as a dedicated buy button, can keep a private label card top of mind as consumers shop on an issuer’s website or app. When paired with tokenized credentials and streamlined authentication, these features can simplify checkout while keeping payments connected to the broader loyalty ecosystem.

Modernization also means preparing for what comes next. As artificial intelligence takes on a greater role in commerce, private label programs should begin planning for agentic commerce, in which AI agents help consumers navigate purchases or initiate transactions on their behalf.

As consumers delegate more actions to digital interfaces, issuers including private label card issuers will need credentials and payment infrastructure that support secure, controlled integration with AI-driven shopping experiences.

But digital innovation shouldn’t come at the expense of the physical card. For many customers, a physical card remains the primary entry point to a payment and loyalty program—and a tangible reminder of the brand. Combined with contactless functionality and digital capabilities, it can help bridge the gap between in-store and online interactions.

The opportunity lies in making physical and digital cards work together as part of a cohesive payment experience.

The Choices Facing Issuers

While digital capabilities across mobile apps and e-commerce are becoming a non-negotiable, issuers still have important decisions to make about the future of their programs.

Some may choose to preserve the traditional closed-loop model to maintain greater control over acceptance, costs, and the customer experience. Others may seek to expand beyond those boundaries.

One option is to co-badge a private label card with an international payment network, allowing customers to retain program perks while using the card across a wider range of merchants and payment environments. Alternatively, issuers may expand acceptance via partner networks that connect their credentials to new use cases.

Technology choices also influence these possibilities. Proprietary contactless technologies may suit programs that prioritize tightly controlled, closed-loop acceptance, while EMV-based solutions can support interoperability depending on the implementation.

Ultimately, these decisions should reflect the program’s specific objectives. A retailer, for instance, may prioritize repeat purchases at its own stores, while an employee benefits provider may need credentials accepted across a larger merchant network.

There is no universal acceptance strategy for private label programs. The right approach depends on the issuer’s business model, customer expectations, and long-term growth ambitions.

The Key Commerce Enabler

As payment technologies and customer preferences continue to evolve, modernizing a private label program is no longer simply a matter of adding a digital feature or replacing an outdated card. Issuers need a holistic strategy that preserves the control and loyalty advantages of private label products while minimizing friction and vulnerabilities.

When calibrated effectively, private label cards can be more than a payment method. They can serve as a powerful tool for customer engagement and long-term growth.

However, modernization can also be complex, requiring issuers to navigate decisions around security, credential management, digital enablement, and acceptance. Choosing the right technology partner is therefore critical.

Technology providers such as IDEMIA Secure Transactions can help issuers define and execute a modernization roadmap, from EMV and contactless migration to digital card enablement and e-commerce readiness such as one click payment options and agent-driven transactions.  They can also support more advanced capabilities, including tokenization strategies designed to connect physical and digital payment experiences securely.

“Major leading private label payment schemes have already invested in their own tokenization capabilities by partnering with IDEMIA Secure Transactions and leveraging our expertise,” Weaving said. “By issuing proprietary network tokens, they can gain greater control over digital payment experiences while strengthening security across their ecosystems.”

“For a private label card issuer, tokenization is not just a security upgrade, it is a key enabler of digital commerce, customer experience, and card usage—enabling wallets, card-on-file, one-click checkout, and other frictionless commerce experiences,” he said.

Modernizing a private label card program effectively means considering how the overall payment experience needs to evolve. For issuers exploring how to make that transition effectively, our position paper takes a deeper look at the key considerations and recommended strategies for building a modern private label payment experience.

Download the position paper, “Are Private Label Cards Ready for the Next Generation of Secure Payments?”, to access these recommendations.

Exit mobile version