PaymentsJournal
SUBSCRIBE
  • Analysts Coverage
  • Truth In Data
  • Podcasts
  • Videos
  • Industry Opinions
  • News
  • Resources
No Result
View All Result
PaymentsJournal
  • Analysts Coverage
  • Truth In Data
  • Podcasts
  • Videos
  • Industry Opinions
  • News
  • Resources
No Result
View All Result
PaymentsJournal
No Result
View All Result

Why Durbin Will Kill the Branch

Brett King by Brett King
March 26, 2012
in Industry Opinions
0

Beautiful woman enjoying life at the beach. Summer vacation concept

0
SHARES
0
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on LinkedIn

In the United Kingdom and Australia, account keeping fees are nothing new. In the United States, however, since the introduction of the Durbin Amendment, many U.S. banks have been moving to monthly fees on checking accounts (we call them current accounts generally outside of the U.S.) for the first time. These moves have resulted in often massive backlash from the public, including social media campaigns, “Bank Transfer Day” and further fuel for the Occupy Movement.

In the U.S., there are actually people you meet who will tell you that free checking is, or at least should be, a constitutional right. Thus, emotion runs high when a bank suggests that you now have to start paying for the right to keep YOUR money with their bank – it’s an outrageous concept to many!

The biggest problem for the U.S. banking industry is that for the longest time it trained customers to believe that this was exactly how they should feel, what they should demand. Advertisers promoted ‘free checking’ for decades as the basic hook for new customers, although it could hardly be called a differentiation. The logic is that there is nothing better than free to attract customers to a new service platform. So how did banks pay for ‘free checking’?

Not Really Free

Well, it was never actually free. Banks initially made money off deposits (or Assets under Management), but as regulations tightened in the last two decades, rates dropped and spreads decreased, margins became razor thin. In th 80s as interest rates climbed, some banks instituted basic fees to combat the cost of savings accounts, but when credit cards became popularized in the 90s, banks now had fallback sources of revenue in credit fees and interchange that could sustain ‘free checking’. A side effect of the global financial crisis is that credit card usage has declined as consumer “saving has become the new spending”, this means that a credit card isn’t working as an offset against basic account costs. With interest rates at historical lows and with no immediate signs of improvement, basic account profitability is at further risk. Then to add to all of this pressure along came the U.S Senator from Illinois, Dick Durbin.

The Durbin Amendment to Dodd-Frank, has cut off the lifeblood of interchange fee from larger institutions, many of whom claim it will cost Billions in lost revenue. So while account keeping fees are seen as a mechanism to claw back loses on interchange, I expect it will have a secondary, more subtle consequence on retail banking.

Branch Economics Fail

In the light of revised economics of interchange and debit cards, the first reaction to loss of interchange fee in the US was to try to find new sources of revenue. However, the second reaction inevitably will be a realization that the cost base banks carry to support checking accounts via the branch is no longer viable – network is simply a luxury in a world where consumers just aren’t utilizing physical spaces for their relationship. With the best customers only visiting branches occasionally as they become increasingly digitally enabled, the expense of sustaining a network for a core product or relationship which looks more and more like a cost than a profit, becomes rapidly apparent.

The UK has had more than a decade to deal with this, which is undoubtedly why the UK has halved the number of retail bank branches since 1990. The US, with the false economics of consumer credit and interchange, have paid for their bloated physical infrastructure without the realization of the cost of changing behavior on their distribution model. That realization is now hitting hard as the real costs of an outmoded business model hit home.

Unintended Consequences

The Durbin Amendment will give banks the imperative to better manage the economics of their debit card and checking account business. As they are forced to be more disciplined around metrics, two issues will emerge. The first, that while the economics of branch banking are oft justified as supporting high-net worth customer interactions, that increasingly this demographic is moving to digital channels and the branch is no longer the lynchpin in this coveted relationship. How can it be when I use my mobile or internet to talk to the bank 30 times a month, but I visit the branch only twice a year? Secondly, the least profitable customers also are laggards to digital (largely due to adoption cost) and rely more heavily on tree-killing paper statements, ‘free’ checks and over-the-counter interactions.

Once you’re forced to re-examine your cost base in the light of changing distribution, behavior and regulation, the realization emerges that branches are not the profit centre they once were, but are now largely a cost that was hidden by the buffer of high interchange and credit card fees. Couple this with new challenges to the distribution model through Internet direct banks and non-bank FIs who offer better savings rates and lower fees on the basis of better economics, and branch banking will be mercilessly attacked by the big banks looking to retain their earnings-per-share.

The unintended consequences of Durbin may very well be the rapid unwinding of branch banking in the U.S. It takes a long time to turn the ship, but once that turn starts the momentum of branch closures will speed up rapidly.

Brett King, best selling Author of BANK 2.0, is a renowned public speaker, blogger, and advisor to some of the world’s biggest financial services organizations and leading brands. He is also the founder of a number of non-profit associations. This Industry Perspective originally appeared on King’s personal blog and is republished here with his permission. It has been edited to conform to PaymentsJournal.com’s editorial style.

Tags: Banking ChannelsCompliance and Regulation
0
SHARES
0
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on LinkedIn

    Analyst Coverage, Payments Data, and News Delivered Daily

    Sign up for the PaymentsJournal Newsletter to get exclusive insight and data from Javelin Strategy & Research analysts and industry professionals.

    Must Reads

    digital value

    How Embracing Digital Value Can Help Solve the B2C Payments Conundrum

    June 1, 2023
    instant payments, real-time payments, RTP

    Banks Developing Instant Payments Products in the U.S. Should Focus on Billers to Generate New Revenue Streams  

    May 31, 2023
    Digital Wallet Use Delivers on Convenience and Security

    Digital Wallet Use Delivers on Convenience and Security

    May 30, 2023
    5 Ways to Protect Your Financial Institution from a Cyberattack

    5 Ways to Protect Your Financial Institution from a Cyberattack

    May 26, 2023
    traditional banks

    How Traditional Banks Can Modernize Without Risk

    May 25, 2023
    identity fraud

    Javelin’s Identity Fraud Study Highlights the Changing Nature of Fraud

    May 24, 2023
    SASE, security-as-a-service

    Security-as-a-Service Secures
    Distributed IT Models

    May 23, 2023
    mule. real-time

    Early Detection of Mule Activity Requires Real-Time Solutions

    May 22, 2023

    Linkedin-in Twitter

    Advertise With Us | About Us | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Subscribe
    ©2023 PaymentsJournal.com

    • Analysts Coverage
    • Truth In Data
    • Podcasts
    • Videos
    Menu
    • Analysts Coverage
    • Truth In Data
    • Podcasts
    • Videos
    • Industry Opinions
    • Recent News
    • Resources
    Menu
    • Industry Opinions
    • Recent News
    • Resources
    • Analysts Coverage
    • Truth In Data
    • Podcasts
    • Industry Opinions
    • Faster Payments
    • News
    • Jobs
    • Events
    No Result
    View All Result

      Register to download this complimentary report from Brightwell: