Why Sharing Data Is Vital to Fighting Fraud

fraud intelligence sharing

Fraudsters have learned that sharing information gives them an advantage. So why are so many financial institutions still reluctant to do the same? Despite growing recognition that pooling intelligence can help detect and prevent financial crime, banks continue to hesitate, citing concerns ranging from competitive advantage or customer privacy.

In a PaymentsJournal Podcast, Anurag Mohapatra, Product Director of Fraud Prevention and Authentication Management at NICE Actimize, and Jennifer Pitt, Senior Analyst of Fraud Management at Javelin Strategy & Research, discussed why those objections need to be overcome and what is standing in the way of broader intelligence sharing.

Where Things Stand

There is growing global momentum around fraud intelligence sharing, but approaches vary by region, largely in response to different regulatory environments. Asian nations tend to favor centralized structures. In Japan, for example, the Financial Services Agency mandates intelligence sharing among banks.

Europe’s Payment Systems Regulation, expected to roll out in early 2028, will mandate information sharing while allowing financial institutions to determine how they participate.

The U.S. currently has no requirement for banks to participate in intelligence-sharing networks. A proposed bill known as the TRACE Act would clarify some of the legal barriers that have prevented institutions from building and participating in such networks. There has also been recent clarification around Section 314(B), including what can be shared in real time and for what purposes.

Measures that encourage data sharing rather than mandate it could help remove some of the roadblocks that have kept banks from participating voluntarily. Australia, for instance, initially established a voluntary information-sharing network that included telecommunications companies, social media platforms, and banks. That system eventually evolved into a framework requiring participation.

Reasons for the Reluctance

Beyond regulatory concerns, more informal barriers have also made banks hesitant to collaborate. Competition for business remains one factor, with some institutions reluctant to share information that could potentially benefit a rival.

“When we have conversations with larger banks, there will be one guy who says, ‘I’m sending 60% of all the fraud data that the network has. Am I getting enough in return?” said Mohapatra.

There’s also a tendency to conflate intelligence sharing with information sharing. Banks are naturally protective of the financial data they possess. That mindset has contributed to a decade of sharing patterns and insights rather than actionable intelligence about counterparties.

“But in the last two to three years, banks have been reaching out to us saying, ‘Hey, can you bring this idea to the rest of the network?’” said Mohapatra. “Can we have a forum where we can discuss this idea with our peers? The willingness is there now more than in the past.”

The good news is that consumers may be more comfortable with intelligence sharing than banks assume, provided they understand how their data is being handled.

“One of the interesting things that we hear from consumers is that they are OK with having their bank share information with other banks for the purpose of fraud prevention as long as they know what information is being shared and why,” said Pitt. “Especially with all the data breaches that have been happening lately, they want to know where the data is going, and what it’s being used for. Being transparent with your consumers is really key.”

Keeping the Data Anonymous

Banks don’t necessarily need customers’ personal information to detect fraud in real time. Real-time intelligence-sharing platforms can use data such as account and routing numbers, along with transactional behavior. Factors including transaction frequency, transaction amounts, and how often a payment is credited can provide useful indicators without exposing personally identifiable information.

The account and routing numbers shared across the network can also be pseudonymized, helping protect customer information while still allowing institutions to identify suspicious activity.

A broad network can spot behavior before any individual financial institution. It may detect a pattern or possess proprietary intelligence that is not yet visible to a single institution. The challenge is that fraud intelligence can become stale quickly. The network’s lead time currently averages three to five days, although organizations are working to reduce that window.

“Consortiums like the ones we operate are proving that real-time information sharing is possible,” said Mohapatra. “Information can be refreshed as quickly as overnight. It all depends on the willingness of FIs.”

Investing in Intelligence Sharing

For the most part, organizational fraud leaders recognize the value of investing time and resources in intelligence sharing. Convincing business partners is another matter.

“If I were in their shoes, I would not just make the case about fraud,” said Mohapatra. “One of my clients says that fraud is only 2% of the problem, and 98% of my transactions are legit transactions. But for the 98%, I’m also improving the customer experience.”

The financial impact of fraud extends beyond the initial loss to the victim. Javelin’s research found that 31% of fraud victims closed their accounts at the institution where the fraud occurred. That finding underscores how fraud prevention can play a role in customer retention and, ultimately, business growth.

However, fraud controls need to be effective without becoming so onerous that they drive away potential or existing customers.

“A bank can provide a better service by reducing the amount of friction,” Mohapatra said. “If there’s a large outgoing wire for a commercial client, do we really need to hold it and get the customer on the call? If we can reduce that amount of time, if we can reduce the friction that we introduced in that process, it would be much better.”

The recent scrutiny of Zelle offers an instructive example. Fraud occurring on the network drew significant attention, including Senate hearings and extensive negative coverage, even though the vast majority of transactions on the network were legitimate.

As a result, some users became wary of the service. But that story had a happy ending.

“That spotlight and the apprehensions that customers had affected the service provider so much that they rolled out a feature around built around information sharing for fraud prevention,” Mohapatra said. “That’s what more banks are going to experience.”

Exit mobile version