PaymentsJournal
SUBSCRIBE
  • Analysts Coverage
  • Truth In Data
  • Podcasts
  • Videos
  • Industry Opinions
  • News
  • Resources
No Result
View All Result
PaymentsJournal
  • Analysts Coverage
  • Truth In Data
  • Podcasts
  • Videos
  • Industry Opinions
  • News
  • Resources
No Result
View All Result
PaymentsJournal
No Result
View All Result

I Scream About Credit Card Surcharging

Brian Riley by Brian Riley
August 20, 2021
in Analysts Coverage, Credit, Merchant
0
I Scream About Credit Card Surcharging

I Scream About Credit Card Surcharging

0
SHARES
0
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on LinkedIn

If you ever had the opportunity to read this study by the Federal Reserve, you’d have a pretty good understanding of merchants, interchange, and the consumer impact. The study examines what happened to consumer prices after Dodd-Frank imposed debit interchange price controls. The short story, summarized on page 12, is: “little empirical evidence has been reported on the change of merchant prices due to the debit interchange regulation.”

Simply put- if you reduce interchange, the money goes into the merchant’s pocket, not the consumer’s wallet (or purse).

That is what makes the issue of credit card surcharging counterintuitive.Today’s WSJ offers an attention-grabbing headline as it shouts, “Paying with a Credit Card? That’s Going to Cost You.”

The article begins with:

  • More small businesses—and even some larger ones—are charging shoppers a fee for credit-card purchases or offering them discounts when they pay with debit cards, cash, or checks.
  • The moves are meant to offset the various fees businesses pay on credit-card transactions, costs that have grown alongside generous cash-back and travel rewards.

Surcharging is not the mainstay in payments today, but the concept is straightforward. As you settle your bill with a merchant, the merchant adds a fee on top of the purchase. In the example, WSJ offers, a $5 ice cream purchase adds 25 cents at the point of sale.

As a consumer, I’d steer away from a business that surcharges. It seems like a sleight of hand to raise consumer costs. The merchant already has an expense for handling cash, as they do with taking any payment form. They do not disclose the cost of goods sold at the point of sale. So why single out the processing cost?  It has more to do with incrementing revenue than it does to reduce expenses. 

If the credit card interchange was 1.75%, then the actual processing cost was closer to $0.09, a pittance compared to the merchant’s $0.25 upcharge. Moreover, if pricing included the total merchant fees associated with smaller merchants, closer to $0.66 fully loaded, that cost is not just interchange; it contains all other merchant services for statement rendition acceptance, capital equipment, and related expenses. That is an area regulators miss when they attack interchange.  Payment networks set the interchange rates but do not earn revenue from the interchange. Also, processors add on fees to cover their risks, expenses, and margins.

Let’s use a more practical example.

At Fastfoodmenuprices.com, the cost of a large ice cream cone is $4.99 at Ben and Jerry’s.  Add on a chocolate-dipped waffle cone, and that is another $1.49.  Throw on sprinkles for another $0.29, and with tax, the ice cream cone is about $7.00. Just to put the revenue dynamics into the equation, this site says a commercial 3-gallon tub of ice cream is $30, and there are 55 four-ounce scoops in the container, with an average cost per scoop of $0.47.  With a suggested markup of 333% to 416%, the merchant has plenty of margin to support their payment processing

When it comes to small businesses and credit card surcharging, the more significant issue seems that the consumer will not see the savings, but the merchant will benefit. Perhaps the broader point is that the mom-and-pop store will have to pay income taxes because the transaction is now documented in the credit card transaction and not presented as an anonymous cash transaction.

Either way, this is August and everyone loves ice cream.  Many more than those who like credit card surcharging.

Overview provided by Brian Riley, Director, Credit Advisory Service at Mercator Advisory Group

Tags: Credit CardsMerchant
0
SHARES
0
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on LinkedIn

    Analyst Coverage, Payments Data, and News Delivered Daily

    Sign up for the PaymentsJournal Newsletter to get exclusive insight and data from Javelin Strategy & Research analysts and industry professionals.

    Must Reads

    deposit fraud

    Early Warning’s Verify Deposit Risk Leverages Predictive Intelligence to Stop Deposit Fraud

    November 28, 2023
    financial management

    How Intuit QuickBooks is Providing Tools for More Effective Financial Management at Every Stage of Small Business Growth

    November 27, 2023
    credit cards

    Credit Card Industry Remains Robust but Must Brace for Economic Instability

    November 22, 2023
    Complaints About Empty Gift Cards Continue into the Holiday Season

    Complaints About Empty Gift Cards Continue into the Holiday Season

    November 21, 2023
    Virtual Cards Are Gaining Ground in B2B Payments

    Virtual Cards Are Gaining Ground in B2B Payments

    November 20, 2023
    API and UI Intersection Accelerates Digital Banking

    API and UI Intersection Accelerates Digital Banking

    November 17, 2023
    fraud AI

    How Turnkey AI Solutions Can Help Payments Stakeholders Mitigate Fraud

    November 16, 2023
    New Mastercard Launch Allows Fast and Secure Cross-Border Payments

    Central Banks and Fintechs Compete to Shape Cross-Border Payments Mobility

    November 15, 2023

    Linkedin-in Twitter

    Advertise With Us | About Us | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Subscribe
    ©2023 PaymentsJournal.com

    • Analysts Coverage
    • Truth In Data
    • Podcasts
    • Videos
    Menu
    • Analysts Coverage
    • Truth In Data
    • Podcasts
    • Videos
    • Industry Opinions
    • Recent News
    • Resources
    Menu
    • Industry Opinions
    • Recent News
    • Resources
    • Analysts Coverage
    • Truth In Data
    • Podcasts
    • Industry Opinions
    • Faster Payments
    • News
    • Jobs
    • Events
    No Result
    View All Result