PaymentsJournal
SUBSCRIBE
  • Analysts Coverage
  • Truth In Data
  • Podcasts
  • Videos
  • Industry Opinions
  • News
  • Resources
No Result
View All Result
PaymentsJournal
  • Analysts Coverage
  • Truth In Data
  • Podcasts
  • Videos
  • Industry Opinions
  • News
  • Resources
No Result
View All Result
PaymentsJournal
No Result
View All Result

PayDay Lending: Out on the Fringes and Still an Ugly Business

Brian Riley by Brian Riley
April 20, 2022
in Analysts Coverage, Credit
0
PayDay Lending: Out on the Fringes and Still an Ugly Business

PayDay Lending: Out on the Fringes and Still an Ugly Business

0
SHARES
0
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on LinkedIn

Credit cards often grab the headlines, but rates are highly regulated, the market is transparent, and competition is stiff. Standard regulations like Reg E and Reg Z ensure a fair lending environment, and regulators like the OCC are there to ensure safe and sound lending. However, for those who maxed out their plastics, or are unable to qualify under bank underwriting standards, PayDay loans can be the only option.

I tried a couple of vendors a few years ago so I could experience the process, and perhaps feel the pain of sky-high interest rates. Call it crazy, but the field test is a good way to understand the business process. And perhaps be the first consumer to read the required disclosures from end-to-end. I did the same with BNPL, and a few non-national credit card companies just out of curiosity or simply professional interest.

The terms for the PayDay loan were notable. At this lender, borrowing $300 for 14 days incurs a $33 finance charge. Certainly, $33 will not kill a household budget, but the annualized interest rate is enough to bring shock to a frugal consumer.

Were you in a household that had a sick child, broken transmission, or inflight bank overdraft pending, the PayDay loan could be a lifesaver if there was no other option. In the experiment, I found the location to resemble a progressive bank branch and the people friendly. The transaction was settled in a matter of moments based on my 30-year-old checking account and a current paystub.

Recent state legislation helped with some of the usurious lending rates, but research by Pew Charitable Trusts points out a new trend. In a recently published study, they found that some banks are now charging more interest than PayDay lending. The article points out the excellent work addressing the credit-invisible market by Bank of America, U.S. Bank, and Huntington Bank, and it brings to light an interesting trend used by PayDay lenders who align with Utah’s quirky industrial banking laws.

According to the Utah Department of Financial Institutions, “industrial banks were also known as industrial loan corporations (ILCs) in Utah until 2004 when state law was amended to rename this class of institution to better reflect their legal status as fully-fledged FDIC insured depository institutions.”

A fledgling trend is the use of rent-a-bank licensing by local PayDay lenders. What is interesting is how the rent-a-bank model allows a licensed state lender to circumvent state interest caps. This is allowable because of a long-ago decision that allows banks to export rates based on the maximum allowable interest rate in the state. This logic is what put Citi’s card business on the map with its move to South Dakota.   

However, in the context of PayDay loans and interstate rate migration, this is an example of interest rates on steroids. Pew cites examples of licensed PayDay lenders moving their rates from 88% to 149% in the state of Ohio, and in Oregon from 154% to 262% APRs. No impact was evident in a few states, but other examples include the states of Hawaii, Oregon, and Washington, where rates moved to 184%, 262%, and 260% respectively.

For now, know that credit card rates do not even approach this lending niche, and that PayDay pricing is high because of the inherent lending risk. But either way, usurious interest rates such as these can only solve a temporary household issue. In the long haul, PayDay lending costs a lot more than traditional bank lending.

A full copy of the report can be found here.

Overview by Brian Riley, Director, Credit Advisory Service at Mercator Advisory Group

Tags: Alternative LendingCreditCredit Card Interest Ratesinterestinterest ratesLendingLoansPayday Lenders
0
SHARES
0
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on LinkedIn

    Analyst Coverage, Payments Data, and News Delivered Daily

    Sign up for the PaymentsJournal Newsletter to get exclusive insight and data from Mercator Advisory Group analysts and industry professionals.

    Must Reads

    credit card tumbling

    How to Detect, and Prevent, Credit Card Tumbling

    January 30, 2023
    Why Businesses Need to Adopt Real-Time Payments as a Competitive Differentiator

    Why Businesses Need to Adopt Real-Time Payments as a Competitive Differentiator

    January 27, 2023
    faster payments

    Faster Payments Are Set to Revolutionize Modern Digital Payments

    January 26, 2023
    How AI can Help Manage Payments Risk in 2023

    How AI can Help Manage Payments Risk in 2023

    January 25, 2023
    cross-border payments

    How to Implement Effective and Innovative Cross-Border Payment Strategies

    January 24, 2023
    credit card experiences, digital payments, b2b payments

    Will Consumer-to-Business Payment Trends Drive B2B Global Growth in 2023?

    January 23, 2023
    Faster Payments Faster Identity Verification, connected car, payments

    2023 Predictions: Authentication, Digital Identity, and In-Car Payments

    January 20, 2023
    bank data

    Interconnectivity, Data Sharing, and Security Are Vital for Banks to Thrive

    January 19, 2023

    • Advertise With Us
    • About Us
    • Terms of Use
    • Privacy Policy
    • Subscribe
    ADVERTISEMENT
    • Analysts Coverage
    • Truth In Data
    • Podcasts
    • Videos
    • Industry Opinions
    • News
    • Resources

    © 2022 PaymentsJournal.com

    • Analysts Coverage
    • Truth In Data
    • Podcasts
    • Industry Opinions
    • Faster Payments
    • News
    • Jobs
    • Events
    No Result
    View All Result

      Register to download the U.S. Bank report - Real-time payments